Volume 6 Number 19 - Tuesday, May 11th, 2004

A Publication of the ORTHODOX CHRISTIAN LAITY

 


Home

 

Orthodox News

• Last Week's Edition

• Archives

• Search Engine

 

Submissions

Policy

Send


Email us



Support Us!

Donations

Nonprofit Ministries

The Orthodox Christian Laity

OCN Website

• The Video -  "A New Era Begins"

 

 

The Orthodox Christian News Service

 


Published by The National Herald, May 7, 2004

In Rare Display of Resolve, Demetrios Defies Patriarch

By Theodore Kalmoukos

BOSTON – The “New Lands” dispute between Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomaios and the Church of Greece’s Archbishop Christodoulos reached a fever pitch on April 30, when the newly broadened Synod of the Ecumenical Patriarchate, convened by the patriarch, took drastic action against the Church of Greece and its prelate Archbishop Christodoulos. The Synod ruled that there will be no direct relations with the Church of Greece and Archbishop Christodoulos will no longer be mentioned in the prayers of the Ecumenical Patriarchate.

In a rare move, Archbishop Demetrios of America took a strong stand against the condemnatory actions against the Church of Greece and its prelate, which for the first time pitted him against his boss. The Herald learned that Archbishop Demetrios made every effort to prevent any extreme outcome from the start of the session of the Holy Synod. Demetrios expressed doubts on whether the Patriarchal Synod had the authority to terminate Eucharistic communion and intercommunion with the head of the Church of Greece, since Archbishop Christodoulos is a prelate of an autocephalous Church. “Our Synod here is not some type of Highest Synod; it does not consist of prelates of autocephalous Churches and thus how can we place Archbishop Christodoulos outside of the Ecclesiastical Diptychs and terminate Eucharistic and administrative communion,” Demetrios told the 41 Synod members.

The archbishop told the Patriarchal Synod that he felt uncomfortable taking action against the Church of Greece and Archbishop Christodoulos. “How am I going to return to America and look our people in the eyes,” Demetrios said, adding, “The majority of the flock of the Church in America derives from Greece.” The Archbishop made extensive reference in the Synod to the ecclesiastical writings and positions of the National Herald.

A week earlier, the Eparchial Synod had advised Archbishop Demetrios to make every effort to find a peaceful solution to the problem that had arisen between the Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Church of Greece.

Patriarch Bartholomaios, who was expecting unanimous support, was surprised by Demetrios’ strong stand. The patriarch actually announced he was going to cut off ties with Archbishop Christodoulos a week earlier, at a meeting held on Saturday April 24. Hierarchs close to Bartholomaios immediately tried to convince Archbishop Demetrios to vote along with the other 40 hierarchs in favor of the decision so it would be unanimous.

Metropolitan Chrysostomos of Ephesus, who had taken a strong position against the Church of Greece and Archbishop Christodoulos, condemned Archbishop Demetrios, calling him "ignorant of history." The metropolitan is an active metropolitan and also a member of the Holy Synod of the Ecumenical Patriarchate. However, he does not reside in Constantinople, as do the other members but rather travels to the Phanar from his permanent residence in Athens. Metropolitan Chrysostomos has frequently attacked Archbishop Demetrios in the past. He also refused to vote for Archbishop Demetrios in his bid for the Archbishopric Throne of America. That’s not to say that Demetrios had no support among the Synod members. Metropolitan Evangelos of Perga, who is one of the most prominent and prudent hierarchs of today’s Ecumenical Patrirachate residing in Constantinople, came to a complete agreement with Archbishop Demetrios.

In the end, however, Archbishop Demetrios, under the Patriarch and his allies, signed the final condemnatory text against the Church of Greece and Archbishop Christodoulos. Still, while his recommendations were not heeded, Archbishop Demetrios played an important role in the final wording of the decision of the Patriarchal Synod, which was read during a special ceremony in the Patriarchal Cathedral of St. George. The ceremony was broadcast live in Greece. The Herald has learned that early drafts of the text used more incendiary language that appeared to be aimed at humiliating the Church of Greece and Christodoulos. After Archbishop Demetrios’ input, the text became somewhat softer. On the following Monday, Archbishop Demetrios held a teleconference with members of the Holy Eparchial Synod of the Archdiocese to update them on the events that took place at the Patriarchate. During the meeting, members of the Holy Synod praised Archbishop Demetrios for his “strong and appropriate stand,” and thanked him for relating to the Patriarchal Synod their wishes not to act against the Church of Greece and Archbishop Christodoulos. When asked what can be expected from this point on, Demetrios appeared to be hopeful that a solution would be found. He also pointed out that the Greek government was attempting to defuse the crisis by sending Minister of Education Marietta Yiannakou to the Ecumenical Patriarchate to try to convince Bartholomaios to find a peaceful solution for the benefit of Orthodoxy and Hellenism.
 

 

Home Archives Search Submissions Support Us

 
 



This Online Newsletter is partially funded by a grant from the Virginia H Farah Foundation

Orthodox News, PO BOX 6954
WEST PALM BEACH FL  33405-6954
USA

Phone:  (517) 522-3656
Fax:  (517) 522-5907